D. The World, 1789–1900 · The World, 1789–1900An Age of Revolutions: Framing the World, 1789–1900
D1 D2 D3 A1.1 A1.2 A2About 70 minutes
Learning goals- I can explain why historians call 1789 to 1900 an age of revolutions, and why they use the idea of a "dual revolution".
- I can name the major themes of this period in every region of the world, not only Europe.
- I can write factual, causal, comparative and evaluative inquiry questions.
- I can sort evidence into primary and secondary sources and organize it with a graphic organizer.
- I can explain how inquiry skills are used outside history class.
Words to know
dual revolution
A term made famous by historian Eric Hobsbawm for the two linked revolutions of this period: the French (political) Revolution and the British Industrial Revolution.
long nineteenth century
A period some historians run from 1789 to 1914, because the changes that started with the French and Industrial revolutions carried on until the First World War.
nation-state
A state whose government claims to represent one nation, a people who see themselves as sharing a language, history or culture.
imperialism
One state or people taking political or economic control over other lands and peoples.
ideology
An organized set of ideas about how society and government should work, such as liberalism, conservatism or socialism.
periodization
Dividing the past into named periods. Periods are choices made by historians, and each choice highlights some things and hides others.
Welcome to the nineteenth century
In 1789, most people on Earth lived under kings, emperors or chiefs. Most were farmers. Most never travelled faster than a horse could run. By 1900, people in many countries voted in elections, worked in factories, read daily newspapers and rode trains. A telegraph message could cross an ocean in minutes.
The same century also saw some of the largest empires in history. By 1900, a handful of industrial powers ruled or dominated most of Africa and much of Asia and the Pacific. Change was fast, but it was not equally shared. This unit asks: who gained, who lost, and how did people everywhere respond?
Why start in 1789 and stop in 1900?
The year 1789 is the start of the French Revolution. Historians use it as a turning point because the Revolution spread new ideas: that power comes from the people, that citizens have rights, and that a nation belongs to its citizens rather than to a king. You met the ideas behind it in the unit The World, 1650–1789 (the Enlightenment and the American Revolution).
The historian Eric Hobsbawm called this period the age of the dual revolution. One revolution was political (France and the other Atlantic revolutions). The other was economic (the Industrial Revolution, which began in Britain). Together they created a new kind of power: industrial nation-states that could build railways, steamships and modern weapons.
The year 1900 is a convenient stopping point, not a wall. Many historians prefer a long nineteenth century from 1789 to 1914. The unit The World since 1900 picks up the story.
The dual revolution: political and industrial change fed each other, and together they gave a few states the power to build huge empires.Five big themes in every region
The curriculum's three overall expectations for this strand (D1, D2, D3) ask you to look at social, economic and political change; at war, revolution and reform; and at new ideas and identity. In practice that means five themes:
- Revolution and independence. France (1789), Haiti (1791–1804), and Spanish and Portuguese America (1810s–1820s).
- Industrialization. Britain first, then Western Europe, the United States, Japan and Russia; and the effects on places that supplied raw materials, such as India, Egypt and the cotton-growing US South.
- New ideologies and nationalism. Liberalism, conservatism, socialism, feminism and nationalism; the unification of Italy and Germany.
- Empire, resistance and reform. The Scramble for Africa; British India; the Opium Wars in China; and reform movements in Qing China, Meiji Japan and the Ottoman Empire.
- Rights and freedom. The abolition of slavery and serfdom; women's rights; and the experiences of Indigenous peoples facing settler colonialism in Canada, the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Argentina.
A to-scale timeline. Notice that events in Haiti, Latin America, China, Japan and Africa are as important to this period as events in Europe.A note on how we study this period
Some lessons in this unit deal with slavery, colonial violence, famine and the dispossession of Indigenous peoples. We study these with care and respect. There is no joke block in those lessons. Many people alive today are descendants of the people in these histories, including First Nations, Métis and Inuit communities in Canada.
Thinking like a historian: questions first
At university, history begins with a question, not a topic. A topic ("the Industrial Revolution") is too big to study. A good question tells you what evidence to look for. Historians use four main types:
- Factual: What happened? When did Haiti become independent?
- Causal: Why did it happen? What did it lead to? Why did the Industrial Revolution begin in Britain?
- Comparative: How were two cases alike or different? How did Japan's response to Western pressure differ from China's?
- Evaluative: How much did it matter? Was it good, for whom? To what extent did industrialization improve the lives of workers by 1900?
Evaluative questions are the kind you will answer in essays. They have no single correct answer, but some answers are much better supported than others.
Primary and secondary sources
A primary source was made at the time: a newspaper, a law, a diary, a photograph, a treaty, a factory wage list, a song. A secondary source was made later by someone who studied primary sources: a textbook, a historian's book, a documentary.
Whether a source is primary depends on your question. A history of the French Revolution written in 1850 is a secondary source about 1789, but a primary source if you are asking how people in 1850 remembered the Revolution.
| Source | Type | Why |
|---|
| The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789) | Primary | Written by the French National Assembly at the time |
| A 2019 biography of Toussaint Louverture | Secondary | Written long after, using older sources |
| A photograph of a Manchester mill, 1890s | Primary | Made during the period |
| This lesson | Secondary (tertiary, really) | A summary of historians' work |
Sorting sources depends on when, by whom and for what question they were made.Just for funFast news, 1858 style: when the first transatlantic telegraph cable opened, Queen Victoria's 98-word greeting to the US president took about 16 hours to get through. The cable failed within weeks. Your group chat is not impressed.
Worked exampleModelled example: Turning a topic into inquiry questions
Topic: the Opium Wars. Write one question of each type and choose the best essay question.
- Factual: When was the Treaty of Nanjing signed, and what did China give up? (1842; it opened five ports to British trade and gave Hong Kong Island to Britain.) Useful, but it only collects facts.
- Causal: Why did Britain go to war with Qing China in 1839? This asks for causes: the opium trade, the trade imbalance in tea and silver, and the Qing ban on opium.
- Comparative: How did the Treaty of Nanjing compare with the treaties Japan signed in the 1850s? This forces you to look at two cases side by side.
- Evaluative: How significant were the Opium Wars in weakening the Qing dynasty? This asks for a judgement you must defend with evidence.
- Choose: The evaluative question makes the best essay because it needs a thesis, evidence and a counter-argument.
Best essay question: "How significant were the Opium Wars in weakening the Qing dynasty?" It uses the historical thinking concept of significance and has room for more than one defensible answer.
Hands-on activityBuild a family "century of change" chart
You need: a sheet of paper, a pencil and 15 minutes with a grown-up or older relative.
- Draw two columns: When you were my age and Now.
- Interview your grown-up about four things: how people travelled, how they got news, what work people did, and how they communicated with faraway family.
- Fill in both columns.
- Circle the change you think mattered most, and write one evaluative question about it (for example, Did smartphones change family life more than television did?).
- Now imagine the same chart for someone born in 1789 and someone born in 1880. Which changes would they list? (Hint: steam trains, telegraphs, factories, newspapers.)
Look for: concrete details in both columns and a question that asks how much or to what extent.
Your turn
1What two revolutions make up the "dual revolution"?
The French (political) Revolution that began in 1789 and the Industrial (economic) Revolution that began in Britain.
2Why do some historians prefer a "long nineteenth century" (1789–1914)?
Because the changes that started around 1789 (new political ideas, industrialization, nationalism, empire) kept developing until the First World War, which was a bigger break than the year 1900.
3Name three revolutions or independence movements in the Atlantic world between 1789 and 1825.
Any three: the French Revolution, the Haitian Revolution, Mexican independence, the wars led by Bolívar and San Martín in South America, Brazilian independence.
4Classify this question: Why did the Industrial Revolution begin in Britain?
Causal. It asks for the reasons something happened.
5Write an evaluative question about the abolition of slavery.
Sample: To what extent did enslaved people themselves bring about the end of slavery in the Atlantic world? Any question that asks for a judgement (to what extent, how significant, how successful) is evaluative.
6A newspaper from 1848 reports on a revolution in Paris. Is it primary or secondary?
Primary: it was created at the time of the event.
7Why is world history in this period not only about Europe?
Because people in Haiti, Latin America, Africa, Asia and the Pacific, including Indigenous peoples, made their own history: they led revolutions, resisted empires, carried out reforms and shaped the global economy.
More practice: warm-up
1In what year did the French Revolution begin?
2Which country did the Industrial Revolution start in?
3What is a primary source?
Evidence made at the time being studied.
4Give one example of a secondary source.
A textbook, a historian's book or article, or a documentary made later.
5Name one of the four types of inquiry questions.
Any one: factual, causal, comparative, evaluative.
More practice: on your own
1Explain how the political and industrial revolutions fed each other.
Political change created nation-states that mobilized citizens and encouraged trade and industry; industrial change gave those states wealth, railways and weapons. Together they made a few powers able to build huge empires. For example, steamships and new rifles helped European states conquer much of Africa after 1880.
2Why might a historian in Ghana or India choose different turning points than one in France?
Turning points depend on what mattered to a region. A Ghanaian historian might stress the end of the Atlantic slave trade or the British conquest of Asante; an Indian historian, the 1857 Rebellion and the start of the Raj. Periodization reflects whose experience is placed at the centre.
3Turn the topic "the Meiji Restoration" into a comparative question.
Sample: How did Meiji Japan's reforms compare with the Ottoman Tanzimat reforms in their aims and results?
4A history of the French Revolution written in 1847 is being used to study how people in the 1840s saw 1789. Is it primary or secondary for that question? Explain.
Primary. For a question about how people in the 1840s thought, a book from 1847 is evidence created at that time, even though it is a secondary source about 1789.
5Name a job outside of history teaching that uses the skills in this lesson, and explain how.
Examples: a journalist writes questions and checks sources; a lawyer gathers and weighs evidence; a policy analyst compares cases; an archivist organizes primary sources. All of them ask good questions and judge evidence.
Challenge
1Critique the claim: "1789 is the start of the modern world."
Support: 1789 spread ideas of popular sovereignty, rights and citizenship that shaped later revolutions. Against: Industrial change in Britain began decades earlier; the American Revolution (1775–1783) came first; and for many people in Asia and Africa, the decisive changes came later with colonial conquest. A strong answer concludes that 1789 is a useful but Eurocentric turning point, and says which other dates matter for other regions.
2Rank three of the unit's five themes by how much they changed the lives of ordinary people worldwide by 1900. Justify your top choice.
Sample: 1. Empire (by 1900 hundreds of millions of people in Africa and Asia lived under colonial rule); 2. Industrialization (changed work and trade even where there were no factories, e.g., Indian handloom weavers lost markets); 3. Revolution (changed government mostly in the Atlantic world). Other rankings are fine with evidence.
3Explain why the same source can be primary for one question and secondary for another, using an example from this period.
Primary or secondary depends on the question, not the object. Example: Thomas Carlyle's The French Revolution (1837) is a secondary account of 1789, but a primary source for how British writers in the 1830s viewed revolution. A historian must always ask: created when, by whom, and evidence of what?
Check your understandingQuiz
1. Which pair of events did Eric Hobsbawm call the "dual revolution"?
2. Which is an evaluative question?
3. A diary written by a mill worker in 1840 is best described as:
4. Why do some historians use a "long nineteenth century" ending in 1914?
5. Which theme does the Scramble for Africa belong to?
6. Which question is comparative?
For parents and teachersBig idea: This lesson introduces Strand D (The World, 1789–1900; overall expectations D1, D2 and D3) and practises Strand A skills: formulating questions (A1.1), selecting and organizing evidence (A1.2) and transferable skills (A2).
How to help: Ask your teen to explain the "dual revolution" in their own words. Then pick any news story and ask for a factual, a causal, a comparative and an evaluative question about it.
Common difficulties: Writing questions that are too broad ("What happened in the 1800s?"); treating world history as "Europe plus the rest". Encourage your teen to name an example from Africa, Asia, Latin America and an Indigenous nation in every big answer.
Sensitivity: Later lessons cover slavery, colonial violence and famine. They are written without graphic detail.
Expectation codes: The ministry's specific-expectation numbers for Strand D could not be confirmed from an online source, so lessons list the overall expectations (D1, D2, D3). Strand A uses specific codes confirmed in a ministry-linked chart (A1.1 to A1.4, A1.7 to A1.9) and the overall code A2.