Grade by Grade
B. Life Systems · Cells

Plant Cells and How They Compare to Animal Cells

B2.2 B2.3 A1.3 A3.3About 60 minutes
Learning goals
  • I can identify the cell wall, chloroplasts and large central vacuole in a plant cell and explain their jobs.
  • I can compare the structures of plant and animal cells, and explain the differences by their functions.
  • I can recognize a cell as plant or animal from a picture or description.
  • I can design, build and test a model of a cell.

Words to know

cell wall
A stiff layer outside the cell membrane of plant cells. It is made mostly of cellulose and gives support and protection.
cellulose
A tough material made by plants from sugar. It forms plant cell walls; wood, cotton and paper are mostly cellulose.
chloroplast
An organelle in some plant cells that contains the green substance chlorophyll and carries out photosynthesis.
chlorophyll
The green substance in chloroplasts that absorbs light energy for photosynthesis.
central vacuole
The large vacuole in a plant cell. It stores water and pushes outward to keep the cell firm.
turgor pressure
The pressure of water in the central vacuole pushing outward against the cell wall. It keeps plants firm and upright.

Why doesn't a tree flop over?

You have a skeleton to hold you up. A 30-metre white pine has no bones at all, yet it stands straight through storms and heavy snow. A tree also doesn't eat. It makes its own food from sunlight. Both of these facts are explained by structures found in plant cells but not in animal cells.

Plant cells have all the parts you learned last lesson: a nucleus, cell membrane, cytoplasm and mitochondria. (Yes, plants need mitochondria too! Plant cells do cellular respiration to release energy from the sugar they make.) But they also have three special features.

cell wallnucleuscytoplasmchloroplastcell membranevacuolemitochondrion
A typical plant cell from a leaf (not to scale). The cell wall is the outer layer, just outside the cell membrane. The large central vacuole takes up much of the cell, pushing the other parts towards the edges.

Three plant-cell features

1. Cell wall. A stiff layer outside the cell membrane, made mostly of cellulose. It gives the cell a fixed, often box-like shape, supports the plant and protects the cell. Water and dissolved substances pass through it easily; the cell membrane, just inside it, is still the part that controls what enters the cell. Wood, paper and cotton are mostly cellulose from plant cell walls.

2. Chloroplasts. Green organelles containing chlorophyll. Remember from Grade 7: photosynthesis uses light energy to turn carbon dioxide and water into sugar (glucose) and oxygen. This happens in the chloroplasts. Only plant cells that get light, mostly in leaves and green stems, have chloroplasts. Root cells and the cells of an onion bulb have none.

3. Large central vacuole. One big vacuole that can fill much of the cell. It stores water (plus some sugars, salts and wastes). When it is full, it pushes outward against the cell wall. This turgor pressure keeps the cell firm, like air in a bike tire. When a plant doesn't get enough water, its vacuoles shrink, the cells go soft and the plant wilts.

Box-shaped plant cells of a pondweed leaf, each filled with many small green chloroplasts, seen through a light microscope.
In this Elodea leaf you can see two plant-cell features at once: the stiff cell walls that give each cell its box shape, and the green chloroplasts where photosynthesis happens. AI-generated image
FeaturePlant cellAnimal cell
NucleusYesYes
Cell membraneYesYes
CytoplasmYesYes
MitochondriaYesYes
Cell wallYes (cellulose)No
ChloroplastsYes, in cells that get lightNo
VacuoleOne large central vacuoleSmall vacuoles, or none
ShapeFixed, often box-likeFlexible: round, flat, long or irregular
Shared parts are at the top; differences are in bold.

Structure fits function

The differences make sense when you think about how plants and animals live:

  • Plants make their own food using light, so they need chloroplasts. Animals eat food, so they don't.
  • Plants don't have skeletons. Stiff cell walls plus water-filled vacuoles pushing outward hold the plant up. Animals have skeletons (or shells) for support, and their flexible cells let them move and change shape.
  • Plants can't walk to a lake for a drink, so the large vacuole stores water between rains.

Note: fungi cells (like mushrooms and yeast) also have cell walls, but they are made of a different material, and fungi have no chloroplasts.

Contributions to science: where did mitochondria and chloroplasts come from?

In 1967, the American biologist Lynn Margulis published the idea that mitochondria and chloroplasts were once free-living bacteria that were taken inside other cells long ago and stayed, helping each other survive. Many scientists rejected her idea at first. But evidence built up: mitochondria and chloroplasts have their own DNA and divide on their own inside the cell, much like bacteria. Today her idea (called endosymbiosis) is widely accepted. It shows how a scientist with a new perspective, who kept gathering evidence, changed what everyone thought.

Worked example

Let's identify the cell

Under a microscope you see cells that are rectangular, with a thick outline, a nucleus near one side and a large clear area in the middle, but no green structures. Is this a plant or animal cell? Could it be from a leaf?

  1. A thick outline around a box-like shape suggests a cell wall. Animal cells don't have walls.
  2. The large clear middle is likely a large central vacuole, another plant feature. It has pushed the nucleus to one side.
  3. No chloroplasts, so the cell is from a part that doesn't get light, like a root or an onion bulb. A leaf cell would usually show green chloroplasts.

It is a plant cell, probably from a root or onion bulb, not from the green part of a leaf.

Worked example

Let's explain wilting

A basil plant on the windowsill is drooping on Friday. After you water it, it stands up again by Saturday. Explain using plant-cell structures.

  1. Without enough water, the central vacuoles in the plant's cells lost water and shrank.
  2. With less water pushing outward, turgor pressure dropped. The cells went soft, and the stems and leaves drooped.
  3. After watering, the roots took in water. It moved up the stem and into the cells, refilling the vacuoles.
  4. The full vacuoles pushed against the cell walls again, and the cells became firm.

Wilting = low turgor pressure from shrunken vacuoles. Watering refills the vacuoles, which push on the cell walls and make the plant firm again.

Watered: vacuole fullDry: vacuole shrunkencentral vacuolevacuolepushes on the cell wall: firm (turgid)little push on the wall: soft cellsplant stands upplant wilts
Left: a full central vacuole pushes outward on the cell wall (turgor pressure), so the cells are firm and the plant stands up. Right: the vacuole has lost water, the cells go soft and the plant wilts.
Just for fun

Why did the plant cell stay calm during the windstorm?

It had high turgor pressure and a really supportive cell wall.

Hands-on activity

Engineering design: build a 3-D cell model

Challenge: design and build a 3-D model of a plant cell or an animal cell that clearly shows all its parts and how it differs from the other type.

Criteria: all the parts for your cell type are shown and labelled; sizes and positions make sense (for example, a plant's vacuole is large); it can be handled without falling apart; someone at home can tell from the model whether it is a plant or an animal cell.

Possible materials: a clear zip-top bag (cell membrane); a small clear plastic container or box (cell wall); clear hair gel, or water with a little cornstarch (cytoplasm); a grape, plum or ball of modelling clay (nucleus); dried beans or jelly beans (mitochondria); green peas or green beads (chloroplasts); a smaller water-filled zip-top bag (central vacuole); paper flags on toothpicks (labels).

  1. Plan: sketch your design and list which material is each part, and why.
  2. Build it.
  3. Test: ask someone at home to (a) name each part and (b) decide whether it's a plant or animal cell. Write down what they got wrong or found confusing.
  4. Improve one thing based on the test, and explain what you changed.
  5. Communicate: write 3 sentences comparing your cell with the other type.

Safety: small beads, beans and peas are choking hazards for young children; keep them away from little brothers and sisters. Don't eat materials that have been in the model. Toothpick points are sharp.

What to look for: a plant cell model shows the wall outside the membrane, a large central vacuole and chloroplasts; an animal cell model has none of these. The test-and-improve steps are recorded.

Your turn

1

Name three structures plant cells have that animal cells don't.

2

Name four structures both plant and animal cells have.

3

What is the cell wall made of, and what does it do?

4

What process happens in chloroplasts?

5

Do plant cells have mitochondria? Why?

6

Which is outside the other in a plant cell: the cell wall or the cell membrane?

7

Why don't onion bulb cells have chloroplasts?

More practice: warm-up

1

Which organelle is green?

2

Do animal cells have a cell wall?

3

What do we call the push of water in the vacuole against the cell wall?

4

Which cell type usually has a box-like shape?

5

Which cell type usually has small vacuoles or none?

More practice: on your own

1

Explain how cell walls and vacuoles together let a plant stand without a skeleton.

2

A cell has a cell wall and a large vacuole but no chloroplasts. Can you be sure it is from a plant? Explain.

3

Why would chloroplasts be useless to an animal cell inside your body?

4

Give one way an animal cell's lack of a cell wall helps the animal.

5

What evidence supports Lynn Margulis's idea that mitochondria were once bacteria?

Challenge

1

A Grade 8 student says, "Plants get energy from the sun, so they don't need mitochondria." Explain the error.

2

A leaf cell from just under the top surface of a maple leaf and a cell from a maple root are compared. Predict two differences and explain them.

3

Your cell model uses a zip-top bag for the cell membrane. Explain one way this is a good model and one way it is a poor model.

Check your understanding

Quiz

1.

Which part is found in plant cells but not in animal cells?

2.

Where does photosynthesis happen?

3.

A drooping plant has cells with…

4.

Which statement is true?

5.

The cell wall is mostly made of…

6.

A cell is round, flexible and has no cell wall or chloroplasts. It is most likely…

7.

Lynn Margulis proposed that mitochondria and chloroplasts…

For parents and teachers

Big idea: plant and animal cells share a nucleus, membrane, cytoplasm and mitochondria. Plant cells also have a cell wall, chloroplasts and a large central vacuole, because plants make their own food and must hold themselves up without a skeleton.

How to help at home:

  • Do the wilting test with a houseplant or a stalk of celery left out overnight then placed in water.
  • Build the cell model together. Act as the "tester" and give honest feedback for the improvement step.
  • Ask: "Do plants have mitochondria?" (Yes!) This is the most common misconception.

Safety: small model pieces (beads, beans, peas) are choking hazards for young children. Toothpicks are sharp.

Common difficulties:

  • Thinking plant cells have a wall instead of a membrane. They have both; the wall is outside the membrane.
  • Thinking every plant cell is green. Only cells that get light have chloroplasts.